"Or, to use another simile, mental processes are 'overheard' by the mind whose processes they are, somewhat as a speaker overhears the words he is himself uttering."
— Ryle, Gilbert (1900-1976)
Author
Work Title
Place of Publication
London
Publisher
Hutchinson
Date
1949
Metaphor
"Or, to use another simile, mental processes are 'overheard' by the mind whose processes they are, somewhat as a speaker overhears the words he is himself uttering."
Metaphor in Context
It is naturally difficult, if one denies the existence of the second theatre, to elucidate what is meant by describing the episodes which are supposed to take place in it as self-intimating. But some points are clear enough. It is not supposed that when I am wondering, say, what is the answer to a puzzle and am ipso facto consciously doing so, that I am synchronously performing two acts of attention, one to the puzzle and the other to my wondering about it. Nor, to generalise this point, is it supposed that my act of wondering and its self-intimation to me are two distinct acts or processes indis- solubly welded together. Rather, to relapse perforce into simile, it is supposed that mental processes are phosphorescent, like tropical sea-water, which makes itself visible by the light which it itself emits. Or, to use another simile, mental processes are 'overheard' by the mind whose processes they are, somewhat as a speaker overhears the words he is himself uttering.
(pp. 158-9)
(pp. 158-9)
Categories
Provenance
Reading
Citation
Ryle, Gilbert. The Concept of Mind. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984.
Theme
Soliloquy
Date of Entry
04/27/2013
